Singer vs. Brother Serger Comparison: (Pro Finish vs. 1034D)

Last Updated on November 5, 2023

Hello! It’s Melinda here, and I’m excited to share my thoughts on two popular entry-level sergers: the Singer Pro Finish Serger and the Brother 1034D Serger. In the Singer vs. Brother Serger Comparison, we break down the differences to help you make an informed choice for your sewing projects.

Singer vs. Brother Serger Comparison

Note: Some of the links on this page are affiliate links. This means I will receive a commission if you order a product through one of my links. I only recommend products I believe in and use myself. 


  • Singer Pro Finish allows individual needle adjustment, while Brother 1034D uses a single screw for both needles, offering clear visibility.
  • Singer Pro Finish offers effortless knife disengagement with a press and spin, whereas Brother 1034D uses a lever for stability.
  • Singer Pro Finish has open guides, and Brother 1034D features closed guides for secure thread placement and stability.
  • Both machines have a free arm feature, with Brother 1034D providing easy removal and user-friendly presser foot lifter placement.
  • Both sergers deliver consistent, professional stitches, with slight differences in sound levels, catering to personal preferences.

Singer vs. Brother Serger Comparison

Singer vs. Brother Serger Comparison

In short, the Singer Pro Finish Serger offers precise needle control and open thread guides. At the same time, the Brother 1034D Serger provides stable thread guides, easy stitch customization, and a removable stitch finger.

In this detailed comparison, I’ll be examining various features of these machines, shedding light on their differences and helping you make an informed decision for your sewing needs.

Needle Insertion: Singer Pro Finish vs. Brother 1034D

Needle Insertion
Needle Insertion

One of the key differences between these sergers is how the needles are inserted. The Singer Pro Finish features separate screws for each needle (needles A and B), allowing for precise control during insertion.

In contrast, the Brother 1034D uses a single screw to hold both needles, which some users might find a bit trickier to handle.

However, the Brother serger offers a clear view of both needle positions, ensuring proper alignment.

Upper Knife Disengagement

Upper Knife Disengagement
Upper Knife Disengagement

Disengaging the upper knife is a vital feature of certain sewing techniques. The Singer Pro Finish makes this process simple – a quick press and spin, and the knife is out of the way. On the Brother 1034D, a lever needs to be moved to disengage the knife, offering a stable alternative but with a slightly different mechanism.

Thread Guides and Stability

Examining the thread guides, the Singer Pro Finish has open channels for threading, allowing easy maneuvering of threads.

However, the Brother 1034D’s closed guides offer more stability, preventing threads from falling out even when the machine is moved around. Both machines have their advantages, with the Brother ensuring a more secure hold.

Free Arm Feature and Presser Foot Lifter

Presser Foot Lifter
Presser Foot Lifter

Both machines have a free arm feature, allowing versatility in sewing cuffs and sleeves. The Singer Pro Finish has a handle for easy maneuverability, but users must be cautious about proper placement to avoid tension issues.

On the other hand, the Brother 1034D offers a slightly more user-friendly experience with its easy-to-remove free arm and well-designed presser foot lifter.

Stitching Performance and Sound

Performing a test stitch on both machines, I found the results to be similar regarding stitch quality. The choice boils down to personal preference, as some users find one machine slightly louder than the other.

However, both models deliver consistent, professional-looking stitches suitable for garment construction.

Threading and Tension Adjustment

Tension Adjustment - Singer vs. Brother Serger Comparison
Tension Adjustment

Both sergers provide threading guides, with the Singer Pro Finish featuring a color-coded graphic for easy reference.

The Brother 1034D, on the other hand, has a threading tension release system, simplifying the threading process. Both methods have their merits, catering to different user preferences.

Stitch Options and Adjustability

While both machines offer a variety of stitches, the Brother 1034D allows users to remove the stitch finger for specialized stitching, adding to its versatility.

The Singer Pro Finish integrates the stitch finger, offering convenience without additional parts.


The Singer Pro Finish Serger and the Brother 1034D Serger are solid options for beginners and sewing enthusiasts alike.

FeatureSinger Pro Finish SergerBrother 1034D Serger
Needle InsertionSeparate screws for each needle (A and B)Single screw holds both needles, clear view for alignment
Upper Knife DisengagementSimple press and spin mechanismLever operation to disengage the knife
Thread GuidesOpen channels for threading, maneuverabilityClosed guides for secure thread placement, added stability
Free Arm FeatureIntegrated handle, requires careful placementEasy-to-remove free arm, user-friendly design
Presser Foot LifterTraditional back position, limited extra clearanceRight side position, offers more clearance, great for right-handed users
Stitching PerformanceProfessional, consistent stitches, suitable for garment constructionSimilar stitch quality, slightly louder operation
Threading & Tension AdjustmentColor-coded threading guide, requires careful setupThreading tension release system, simplifies threading
Stitch OptionsVariety of stitches, integrated stitch fingerStitch finger removable for specialized stitching

The choice between these machines ultimately depends on your specific requirements and preferences. Whether you prioritize precise needle control, stable thread guides, or easy stitch customization, both sergers offer valuable features.

Ask any Question Here!