Tide Pods Vs. Liquid – Are Tide Pods Better Than Liquid?

Last Updated on August 12, 2023

In the quest for spotless and soft laundry, the age-old debate between laundry detergents continues: Tide Pods vs. liquid? With the promise of convenience and effectiveness, Tide Pods have gained popularity in recent years.

Tide Pods Vs. Liquid
Image Source: CapitalSauce

Tide pods vs. liquid – Are tide pods better than liquid? 

Which is better Tide PODS or liquid? Yes, Tide Pods are often considered better than liquid detergent due to their convenience, effective cleaning performance, and fresher scent. However, they may be slightly more expensive per load than liquid detergent.

Why Tide Pods are the best?

Tide Pods are the best choice for laundry because of their exceptional cleaning power. Filled with the trusted Tide detergent that has a long history since 1946, these pods are highly effective. In fact, Tide claims they clean ten times better than some budget-friendly alternatives, and our own experience confirms this claim.

When it comes to delivering superior cleaning results, Tide Pods stand out. But are they truly superior to traditional liquid detergents? Here, we’ll dive into the comparison of Tide Pods vs. liquid detergent to determine which one comes out on top.

Tide Ultra Oxi Laundry Detergent Liquid

Tide Ultra Oxi Laundry Detergent Liquid
  • America’s #1 Trusted Detergent Brand
  • Built-in pre-treaters to remove even the toughest stains
  • With a more concentrated formula
  • Measure with cap
  • Helps tackle tough set-in odors

1. Mess-Free Application

The application process is one of the first noticeable differences between Tide Pods and liquid detergent. Liquid detergent can be messy and requires precise measuring with a cup, often leading to spills and excess usage.

On the other hand, Tide Pods offer a hassle-free solution. For small loads, you use one pod; for medium loads, two pods; and for larger loads, three pods. This eliminates the need for measuring and ensures you use just the right amount of detergent, reducing waste.

2. Performance Test

To test the cleaning power of Tide Pods and liquid detergent, we conducted an experiment using red wine stains on six tablecloths. Both products were used in separate wash cycles to determine their stain-removing capabilities.

After a thorough washing and drying process, the results were impressive. Both Tide Pods and liquid detergent effectively removed the wine stains, leaving the tablecloths clean and fresh.

Notably, the tablecloths washed with Tide Pods exhibited a noticeable fresher scent than those washed with liquid detergent.

3. Value Analysis

While both Tide Pods and liquid detergent proved their cleaning prowess, the cost factor plays a significant role in deciding which option to choose. A container of Tide Pods, offering approximately 81 loads, costs around $19.48, translating to roughly 24 cents per load.

On the other hand, a regular-sized container of Tide liquid detergent, providing 64 loads, comes in at $11.97, averaging about 18.7 cents per load. Considering the average family goes through around 350 loads per year, the annual cost difference between Tide Pods and liquid detergent amounts to about $19.

Read More – Is Fabric Softener Bad for Your Washing Machine?

Can I use Tide PODS instead of liquid detergent?

Yes, you can use Tide PODS® instead of liquid detergent. Tide PODS® are convenient and pre-measured, eliminating the need for measuring or pouring messy detergents. They offer an easy and effective way to ensure your clothes are clean and have a pleasant scent. Just toss a Tide POD® into the washing machine, and you’re all set!

Tide PODS Laundry Detergent

Tide PODS Laundry Detergent Soap
  • Surprisingly powerful clean in 1 step
  • Super concentrated detergent
  • Extra stain removers
  • Dissolves completely in any water conditions
  • America’s #1 detergent brand

How much liquid is in a Tide Pod?

A Tide Pod contains 24 ml of liquid detergent, which provides the same cleaning power as 43 ml of Tide Original Liquid detergent used for a medium load of laundry. Over time, the efficiency of Tide Pods has improved, allowing them to handle more laundry loads with a smaller product volume than Tide Liquid.

Video: Tide Pods VS Tide Liquid


In the Tide Pods vs. liquid detergent debate, it’s evident that both options deliver effective stain removal and clean laundry. However, Tide Pods emerge as the winner when considering convenience, mess-free application, and overall cost-effectiveness.

Here’s a simple table summarizing the key points of the comparison between Tide Pods and Liquid Detergent:

AspectTide PodsLiquid Detergent
ApplicationConvenient pods, no measuring neededMessy, requires measuring cup
Cleaning PerformanceEffective stain removalEffective stain removal
ScentLeaves laundry fresherRegular scent
CostAround $19.48 for 81 loads (24 cents/load)Around $11.97 for 64 loads (18.7 cents/load)
ConvenienceHassle-free, no measuringRequires measuring, potential for spills
Annual Cost (350 loads)About $84About $65
OverallConvenient, effective, slightly higher costEffective cleaning with cost advantage

With their precise dosing, ease of use, and only a marginal cost difference, Tide Pods offer an efficient solution for achieving fresh and clean laundry. So, if you want to simplify your laundry routine without compromising quality, Tide Pods are undoubtedly a worthy choice.

Ask any Question Here!