Tide Vs. Persil – Which is Better (After Test)

Last Updated on August 12, 2023

Welcome to the ultimate showdown of laundry detergents – it’s Tide vs Persil! You’re not alone if you’ve ever stood in front of the laundry aisle, pondering which detergent to pick. Both Tide and Persil are heavyweights in the world of laundry cleaning, each boasting their unique features and promises.

Tide Vs. Persil
Image Source: The Clean Psycho

Here, we’re diving deep into the battle of the suds, comparing these two titans to help you make an informed decision. The best way to keep your clothes looking pristine, this comparison will give you the insights you need.

Tide vs. Persil – Stains and Testing Parameters

We’re tackling stains, including sriracha sauce, soy sauce, yellow mustard, Georgia red clay, chocolate sauce, grape juice, barbecue sauce, and transmission fluid. To keep things fair, we’re using a precise fill to ensure accurate water levels, and we’re washing in cold water, which both brands claim to excel in.

We’ll also add a second rinse to gauge its impact. Pre-treating involves applying a teaspoon of detergent to each stain and waiting 30 minutes.

Read More – Are Tide Pods Better Than Liquid?


Persil Laundry Detergent Liquid

Persil Laundry Detergent Liquid
  • Intense Fresh Scent
  • High Efficiency (HE)
  • Deep Stain Removal
  • 2X Concentrated
  • 110 Loads

First up is Persil. After lightly misting the stain, we apply the detergent, then wait and run it through the wash cycle. Post-wash, we see noticeable improvements, especially on sriracha and mustard stains. Persil has managed to impress, leaving only a slight residue on a couple of the stains.


Tide Ultra Oxi Laundry Detergent Liquid

Tide Ultra Oxi Laundry Detergent Liquid
  • America’s #1 Trusted Detergent Brand
  • Built-in pre-treaters to remove even the toughest stains
  • With a more concentrated formula
  • Measure with cap
  • Helps tackle tough set-in odors

Next, we turn our attention to Tide. Using the same method, we pre-treat and run the cycle. After washing, we observe that both brands have their strengths. Tide fares well against sriracha, leaving a slightly cleaner result. However, like Persil, it struggles with certain stains, such as transmission fluid.

The Result

Tide Vs. Persil - Result
Image Source: The Clean Psycho

Upon close comparison, it’s evident that both Tide and Persil have their merits. While Persil shines with its efficient stain removal on specific marks, Tide excels in other areas.

We can’t declare a clear winner, as each brand outperforms the other in different stain categories. The ultimate champion depends on the type of stains you frequently encounter.

FAQ – People also ask

Are Tide and Persil suitable for all washing machines?

Both Tide and Persil are formulated to work well in standard and high-efficiency (HE) washing machines.

BLACK+DECKER Portable Washing Machine

BLACK+DECKER Portable Washing Machine
  • 0.9 Cu. Ft. with 5 Cycles
  • Transparent Lid & LED Display
  • Stainless Steel Tub
  • High Efficiency, Energy Efficiency
  • Designed for Mobility

Can I use Tide or Persil for cold water washing?

Absolutely! Both detergents claim to perform well in cold water, making them energy-efficient choices.

Are Tide and Persil safe for sensitive skin?

Both brands offer variants designed for sensitive skin, which are generally milder and free from certain irritants. Check the product labels for specific information.

How do I choose between Tide and Persil?

Consider your laundry needs. If you deal with specific stains, Persil might be your go-to. If you want an all-around performer, Tide could be the answer.

Can I use Tide and Persil for colors and whites?

Yes, both detergents are suitable for both colored and white laundry. However, always check the labels for any specific instructions.

Do Tide and Persil offer eco-friendly options?

Both brands offer eco-friendly and plant-based detergent options for those looking for more sustainable choices.

Are Tide and Persil suitable for baby clothes?

Both Tide and Persil offer variants that are gentle enough for baby clothes. Always double-check the labels for any additional information.

Can I use Tide and Persil for pre-treating stains?

Yes, you can use both detergents for pre-treating stains. Follow the instructions on the packaging for the best results.

Conclusion – Is Persil better than Tide?

Both brands have strengths: Tide excels in specific stain categories, while Persil shines in others. Consider the types of stains you commonly deal with and choose accordingly. It’s a tie between these two heavyweights, with each offering impressive stain-fighting capabilities.

When choosing between these two heavyweights, consider your laundry needs and the types of stains you frequently face. Whether you opt for the powerful stain removal of Persil or the well-rounded performance of Tide, your laundry is in good hands.

Ask any Question Here!